The short answer
Yes. Hiding negative reviews is now clearly unlawful in the United States. The FTC's 2024 rule on consumer reviews (16 CFR Part 465) bans deceptive review practices. Google's policies also ban review gating, which means asking only the customers you expect to be happy. Asking "how did we do?" first is still allowed. Every customer must keep a clear path to the public review page, no matter how they answer.
What review gating is
The classic gating setup asks every customer "were you happy?" Happy customers go to Google. Unhappy ones quietly go to a private feedback form with no review link. The public rating ends up measuring the filter, not the business. For years this was sold openly as a feature. That time is over.
What the FTC rule changed
The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials took effect in October 2024. It bans buying fake reviews. It bans buying positive or negative reviews. It bans review suppression. It lets the FTC seek civil penalties of over $50,000 per violation. Gating hides or prevents honest negative reviews, so it sits squarely inside what the rule targets.
Google's position
Google's review policies prohibit "discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews, or selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers." Google can remove reviews collected through gating and has penalized listings over how they asked for reviews. Reviews are the asset you are trying to build. Collecting them in a way Google may delete defeats the purpose, even before the legal risk.
What is still allowed, and what ReviewNudger does
You may ask every customer for an honest review. You may offer a private feedback option next to the public one. You may even ask how the visit went before showing next steps. But only if the public review link is shown to every customer, whatever they answer.
By default, ReviewNudger sends every customer the exact same request, with no screening of any kind. A location can choose an ask-first landing page instead, with a quick mood question or short survey. On those pages, the negative and below-threshold paths still always show the public Google review link. That is the line between learning from your customers and gating them. It is built in as a hard rule.
