The short answer
Ask every customer the same way, soon after they pay, with a link that opens your Google review form. Square has its own Google reviews campaign in Square Marketing. It sends to regular customers and to people who leave positive feedback. Or a connected app such as ReviewNudger can ask after each completed Square payment that has a customer email or phone. That costs $29 a month per location, with unlimited texts and emails.
Option 1: Google reviews in Square Marketing
Square’s help center describes a Google reviews campaign under Customers, then Marketing. You sync your Google Business Profile with Square, edit the message, and turn the campaign on. Square lists it for Square Marketing subscribers. In the US, it’s also for Square Plus and Premium subscribers. Check Square’s pricing page for what that costs on your plan today.
The automatic campaign does not ask after every sale. Square says it sends when a customer becomes a regular, or when a customer leaves positive feedback. A regular means three purchases in the last year. You can also send a one-time campaign to a list of customers you pick.
Square’s receipt feedback is a different thing. Customers can rate their visit from a digital receipt. That feedback is private between you and the customer. It never shows on Google.
Option 2: A review app connected to Square
ReviewNudger connects through Square’s own sign-in screen and only listens for payments. A payment might be a card at the counter, an invoice paid online or a Square Appointments checkout. When it’s marked completed in Square, ReviewNudger looks for the customer’s email or phone and applies your sending rules.
At the delay you choose, the customer gets a text with a link that opens your Google review form. New accounts start with that text, then a text reminder two days later and an email reminder five days after that. Follow-ups stop once the customer's Google review shows up in ReviewNudger, or when they send private feedback, reply, or opt out. If ReviewNudger can't check the business's Google reviews, tapping through to Google stops them instead. Texts come from the toll-free number set up for your business once carriers approve it. Email requests can go out while you wait.
The plan is $29 a month per location with a 14-day free trial (card required). It also brings your Google reviews into one inbox with suggested replies. It serves businesses in the US and Canada. No Zapier account is needed for Square.
The catch with walk-in card payments
A tap or swipe at the counter often has no customer attached. With no email or phone on the payment, nobody can be asked, by Square or by any app.
ReviewNudger skips those payments and counts them in your settings. You can see how many sales had no way to ask. The fix is at checkout. Add the customer to the sale, with a mobile number or email saved in your Square customer directory.
How to choose
Four checks settle it for most Square sellers.
- Already paying for Square Marketing, or on Square Plus or Premium? Turn on Square’s Google reviews campaign first. It is already on your bill.
- Want every paying customer asked, not only regulars and people who left good feedback? That is what a connected app does.
- Mostly walk-in sales with no customer details? Neither option can reach those customers. Start by saving a phone number or email at checkout.
- Whichever you pick, turn on only one review tool. Running both can ask the same customer twice.
Tips for appointment businesses on Square
Ask after the visit, not the booking. If you take prepayment when a client books in Square Appointments, that payment is the one that completes. Set a send delay long enough for the visit to happen first.
Watch for fees. A cancellation or no-show fee you charge is also a completed payment. Cancel the waiting request from your dashboard if it shouldn’t go out.
Split payments count once. When two cards pay the same Square order, ReviewNudger keeps them to one request.
Here is an example text. Change the names and add your own link before using it.
Hi Maya, thanks for coming in to Bright Paws Grooming today. Would you share an honest Google review? It helps other pet owners find us: [link]
