The short answer
Google reviews usually disappear for one of four reasons. Google's spam filter removed them. Someone reported them and Google found they broke its content policies. The reviewer deleted the review or their whole Google account. Or your listing changed, through a merge, move, or reinstatement. Spam filter removals are the most common and the hardest to get back. Most reviews the filter takes never come back.
The four usual causes
The most common cause is Google's automatic spam filter. It removes reviews it scores as suspicious, sometimes hours or weeks after they posted. Real reviews get caught for ordinary reasons. The customer reviewed from your shop's wifi. Their account was brand new or had no other activity. Several reviews arrived in a burst. Or the wording matched other reviews too closely.
Second, policy removals. Someone reported the review: you, a competitor, or Google's own systems. Google found it broke its content rules, so it came down. Every review from accounts Google later bans for fake activity comes down too.
Third, the reviewer. People edit and delete their own reviews. When someone deletes their whole Google account, every review they ever left goes with it. Nothing was "removed" as punishment. The author left and took their words along.
Fourth, the listing itself. Google may merge duplicate listings, mark a business as moved, or reinstate a suspended profile. Review counts can then drop or lag while things settle. This is the one cause that tends to hit many reviews at once.
What is recoverable, honestly
Listing problems are the easiest to fix. If a merge or reinstatement swallowed your reviews, Google Business Profile support can often restore them. Bring dates, screenshots, and before-and-after counts. Google never judged these reviews as bad content, so support has something to work with.
Spam filter removals are the opposite. Google doesn't tell you which reviews it filtered or why. There's no way for the owner to appeal someone else's review. In practice, most filtered reviews never return. The reviewer can check their own contribution status in Google Maps. Sometimes they can repost a cleaner version. But chasing single filtered reviews is usually wasted effort.
Reviews the reviewer deleted are simply gone. The author took them down. If it was an unhappy customer you later made things right with, that's the system working as it should.
How to stop feeding the filter
A steady, boring pace is the best protection. Reviews that trickle in all the time, a few every week, matching your real job volume, look natural because they are. Fifteen reviews in one weekend after years of silence look like a bought batch, even when every one is real. So ask after every finished job, not in occasional pushes.
Let customers post from their own phone, on their own account and network, in their own words. Don't hand them a script. Don't have them post from your tablet at the counter. Identical wording and shared devices are exactly what the filter looks for. And never buy reviews or have staff and family post. Those removals are deserved, and enough of them can limit the whole listing.
Keep watch so a drop does not surprise you
You spot a problem faster when the numbers sit where you already look. ReviewNudger pulls your new Google reviews into one dashboard. A stall in new reviews, or a dip after a listing change, shows up in days instead of months. Our free review scanner is the lighter version. Run it now, note your count, and run it again after any listing change.
The other half is making any one lost review matter less. A business that keeps collecting replaces a filtered review within days. That means one review request by text or email after each paid job. A business that never asks feels every removal.
